I almost gave this 2.5 stars but it probably deserves 3.Probably…
For three quarters of the book I was waiting for something to happen. Oh, things happen but not suspenseful things. The most interesting thing was the Chinese lantern festival. That's something I would love to see. But until the very end I wondered if I was even reading a Gothic. Where was the chilling suspense?
and the characters...I just better shut up. No sense in banging imaginary heads together.
This isn't Holt's best. But if you're new to the genre and can read a book without trying to "improve " it in your mind and if don't mind some senseless repetition and rooting for the wrong person then you'll probably enjoy this. But she can do so much better.
CONTENT:
SEX: Behind closed doors, mention of mistresses.
VIOLENCE: Not an issue
PROFANITY: None
PARANORMAL ELEMENTS: Brief mention is made of yarrow sticks, cards and tea leaf reading. Also ancestor spirits not being "happy".
MY RATING: PG
This is a sweet story about a spinstery spinster who conversely is given
a new lease on life when her doctor pronounces a death sentence on her.
"If I have only one year to live", she reasons, "I had better start living"!
I really liked this. At first I wasn't sure if I would. I wanted more
hospital/patient stories and less nurse stories but hello, look at the
title. It is a book about three student NURSES in 1930s East End London.
I'm rather surprised to see several two star ratings for this excellent
book. Were we reading the same thing? I absolutely loved this!
Well, thank goodness that's over!
You really have to ignore the cover on this one. The melancholy boy gives the impression that the book is about overcoming some kind of childhood trauma or abuse, but it's not. This is a memoir of a 1930-40's childhood. You know, snowballs, appendicitis, chewing gum, visiting the dentist, porridge for breakfast, that kind of thing. Nothing angsty at all.
If you look at the dust jacket you'll see a small hotel at the base of a
huge cliff. The cliff has been undermined by an errant mine that washed
into a cave at its base and exploded. No ill effects are noted for some
time. But then cracks appear at the top edge of the cliff and they get
wider..and wider...a note is sent to the owners of the hotel urging them
to abandon the building for safety but the letter goes unopened in a
pile of correspondence and rubbish...
3.5 Stars
What a weird, twisted book. Wow, I can't believe how much I hate this!
And yet I still read 300 pages in hopes that I was mistaken, in hopes
that Jai wasn't a psychopath and Olivia really did have a brain in her
head ...nope
3.5 Stars
I saw this on a Goodreads friend's to-read list and was intrigued. They had it on open
library so I downloaded it "just for a taste", got engrossed and read
it all in two days. (despite reading two other books~ welcome to my
world! :)
I got 28% into this but just lost interest. The story itself is a
fascinating one but I got bogged down in detail, background info and
statistics. I also never fully felt 'in the skin' of the characters
which stunted my emotional response.